To make sure her pie wasn’t awash in liquid, she cut out the evaporated milk. Watch closely at end. If you want to enjoy pumpkin pie without the processed ingredients - this is your pie. And I also agree, less on the sweet side is always better. 1 tsp brandy (optional). Beat eggs, stir in pumpkin and then sugar mixture. Pour filling in pie shell and bake pie at 425 for 15 minutes. Add the maple syrup, ginger, and brandy and continue to whip until medium-firm peaks. Libby’s Famous Pumpkin Pie (without evaporated milk) 3/4 c sugar 1 tsp cinnamon 1/2 tsp salt 1/2 tsp ground ginger 1/4 tsp ground cloves 2 eggs, beaten 1 15 oz can of pure pumpkin 1 12 oz can of evaporated milk 1 c of heavy cream (or milk for fewer calories) Preheat oven to 425, combine dry ingredients in a bowl. Here’s the crust recipe: But I think most of all they liked an excuse to eat as much whipped cream as they liked. So far, the homemade puree is leading. https://www.realsimple.com/.../substitute-for-evaporated-milk They were so similar that it took several bites from each pie to even try to pick a favorite. What I’ve learned this week about homemade pumpkin puree: I am going to burst the bubble of every homesteader raising pie pumpkins everywhere with my next words…. I never realized there was a ‘sweet’ cinnamon. Make the Filling – Whisk together all filling ingredients then add evaporated milk and whisk until smooth. First, I made the pumpkin pie filling. I also have a little friendly competition going on between homemade pumpkin puree and the canned stuff from the store. I’ve been cleaning up my diet for years. pumpkin puree (homemade puree will yield a lighter pie) [Photograph: Robyn Lee] Since it's never too early to start talking pumpkin pie, here's a question: the milk part. Try one of these substitutes for a 12-ounce can (1½ cups) of evaporated milk: 1 cup of whole milk* 1½ cups of milk plus one beaten egg 1½ cups of milk plus 1 Tablespoon of cornstarch 1 cup of half-and-half 1½ cups heavy cream 1 cup of cream plus 1/2 cup regular milk 1½ … 1 cup brown sugar I reduce the sugar in mine to 1/2 or even 1/4 cup. Well, you just covered my two favorites: pumpkin pie and gingerbread. The way I make pumpkin pie, which always gets raves, is to use the Libby’s recipe on the can, but substitute an equal amount of heavy cream for the evaporated milk. More Pumpkin Pie Tips. In terms of other dairy, I have heavy whipping cream, butter, sour cream, and regular 2% milk on hand. Watch closely at end. The pumpkin pie filling uses coconut cream instead of evaporated milk (seriously, what is that stuff!?) For the latest information about Susy and her adventrures, visit the Cultivate Simple site.Thank you for all your support over the years! I just posted something on German pumpkin cheesecake, which is what we’ll be having tomorrow. https://www.theprairiehomestead.com/2014/11/pumpkin-pie-recipe.html The recipe does call for eggs in both the crust and the filling. Cool completely on wire rack, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours before serving (they taste best if made the day before and are refrigerated overnight). Freshly grated ginger tastes so much different than powdered ginger. In our pumpkin bread competition the homemade pumpkin puree beat the canned stuff by a nose. Bake at 350˚F for 60 minutes then cool pie to room temperature. Intend to. The flavor was a bit brighter and the overall bread tasted a little sweeter. I like pumpkin pie with a little bit of cool whip, my Grandma always made her pumpkin pies with butternut squash though. Intend to. [Photograph: Robyn Lee] Since it's never too early to start talking pumpkin pie, here's a question: the milk part. They were both buttery, pumpkin-y and wonderful. The homemade versions are healthier and usually taste better. Please consult the appropriate professional before making any changes to your diet, health, or other applicable areas. Hope you have a fabulous thanksgiving! Following that line of thinking, since Pumpkin Pie has fewer “other” ingredients and lots of pumpkin I thought the homemade pumpkin would really have a chance to shine. If you’re trying to eliminate processed foods – you’ll love it here. Traditionally, pumpkin pie is made with evaporated milk. It's creamy, pumpkin-y and wonderful. PRO. And Enjoy Farm Fresh Meals? Half and half can be substituted for heavy cream, but the texture may suffer. No stores. Get these exclusive recipes with a subscription to Yummly Pro. This is a daily journal of my efforts to cultivate a more simple life, through local eating, gardening and so many other things. I avoid all things processed whenever possible. Thank you for the recipe! If I made it – it is good. I hope it works :O). https://www.realsimple.com/.../substitute-for-evaporated-milk I found a recipe several years ago by Martha Stewart and have used it ever since…and yes, it is a wonderful breakfast food! 2 pies – one from homemade pumpkin puree, one from a can – Identical flavor. Yes. 1 can (15 oz.) Yes, and yes! The sweetened condensed milk and evaporated milk seemed fairly similar to me and were good, but I preferred the heavy cream… lo mein noodles, fresh ginger root, garlic cloves, toasted sesame oil and 8 more. I’ve always used heavy cream – but I bet your pie is wonderful with skim milk…. The recipe couldn’t be any easier either. I love making individual pumpkin puddings in little ramekins during the winter. XO, The piemakers over in Talk are split as to what kind of milk should go into the filling. pinch of freshly ground cloves, whipped cream: Done. A recipe was born. Older recipes for pumpkin pie tend to use half and half, or even just cream for a very rich and silky “pots of creme” style pumpkin pie, akin to eating a pumpkin creme brulee. Best Pumpkin Pie I ever made. Every dedicated baker has strong ideas on how it's best made and will argue eloquently for hours about the selection of ingredients or the correct baking technique. Serve topped with whipped cream. Way richer, creamier, and delicious, and I can use my raw heavy cream or pasteurized organic heavy cream (better at least than conventional evaporated milk). This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. XO, Candi. Well, we had dinner at a friend’s house last night so we had several folks join in the tasting event. So much more creamy richness. roll out the dough with rolling pin beginning in the center and rolling out toward the edges, lift one side of the foil up and drape the pie crust over the rolling pin, continue to let the pie crust drape over the pin until it is balanced and you can move the entire piece, slowly unroll the pie crust off the rolling pin over the pie pan. Can I modify or amend the recipe with anything to make it properly rich? This homemade pumpkin pie recipe calls for any milk or dairy-alternative and other ingredients that you probably already have in the pantry. I made pumpkin pie this year! Bake 425 for 15 minutes then turn the heat down to 350 for 50 minutes to 1 hour. The views expressed here are the author's own. That’s 1/4 …, A Peek Behind the Scenes - March 2019 Sweet, precious …, How to tell if Your Yeast is Dead or Dying …, Pumpkin Pie Recipe (without Evaporated Milk), Homemade Pumpkin Pie – all real ingredients – no evaporated milk. Wishing you and your family a joyous and tasty Thanksgiving. Because I've made a traditional American Thanksgiving dinner in odd places around the world I've had to make substitutions for evaporated milk now and then. Pumpkin Pie Evaporated Milk . Cool on wire rack and serve with whipped cream. 3 people couldn’t even pick a favorite because there was no difference. ✓ BAKE 50 to 55 minutes or until knife inserted one-inch from edge comes out clean. Love it! Sep 8, 2014 - Today let's be thankful for leftovers. If you want to make your pie without those, this recipe is perfect. Pumpkin Pie Filling Ingredients: Pumpkin Puree – make sure you’re using the puree, not the canned pumpkin pie filling. Last night I actually made some [from scratch] ‘pumpkin pie filling’ topped brownies! I shared some with my French roommates and totally converted them to the idea. Bake until center is slightly jiggly and wet, about 1 hour. I am not a doctor and the statements on this blog are based on my own research, knowledge, and experiences. The flavor of sweet cinnamon pairs much better with sweet things, it’s more mellow than regular cinnamon. Homemade pumpkin puree or the canned stuff? Garrick is exactly correct. I’ll admit to eating this for breakfast if I have it in the fridge and not feeling the least bit guilty about it. Today we are making pumpkin pie from scratch. I’m not big on really sweet stuff, this recipe has less sugar than most so it won’t taste like the recipe from the back of the can of pumpkin. Because I've made a traditional American Thanksgiving dinner in odd places around the world I've had to make substitutions for evaporated milk now and then. Learn how your comment data is processed. Combine pumpkin, sugar, evaporated milk, eggs, pumpkin pie spices and salt in mixing ... clean. As my diet has changed, I have had to adapt many of my favorite recipes to include REAL food instead of processed foods. I mean if you were to take of sip of each one side by side which one will taste better? 1 tsp freshly ground cinnamon 2 tbsps maple syrup Pumpkin pie is my favorite thing that comes across the table around the holidays. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving Tip: Heavy Cream vs. Evaporated Milk - Westborough, MA - This post was contributed by a community member. Finally, someone who understands it is not a law that you have to use evaporated milk in a good pumpkin pie! I mean if you were to take of sip of each one side by side which one will taste better? Since I don’t want to eat a clove cigarette I use just cinnamon. This pie can be made up to 3 days before you plan to serve it. Combine 1 1/2 Cups Cream, 2 large eggs, 3/4 Cup Sugar and … Rum Whipped Cream – beat 1 cup heavy cream until soft peaks form then add sugar, rum, and vanilla and beat until medium/stiff peaks form. The pumpkin bread from the homemade puree was better; I thought the pie would be a land-slide in the favor of homemade puree. Add salt, cinnamon and pumpkin & whisk again. Ultimately, I found heavy whipping cream to be the best. or heavy cream. In stead of using cinnamon, cloves and ginger I am using just cinnamon (when pumpkin pies have too much spice they taste like a clove cigarette to me). Classic Lo Mein Noodles Chef Jet Tila. 1 12 oz can of evaporated milk 1 c of heavy cream (or milk for fewer calories) Preheat oven to 425, combine dry ingredients in a bowl. I’m baking 2 pies that will be identical except for the origins of the pumpkin. This pumpkin pie is everything you expect in a pumpkin pie. The best Pumpkin Pie I have ever made! Pipe over cooled slices of pie. *To bake in a pie shell, heat oven to 425. Healthy eating without the overwhelm. Let cool & serve with a dollop of whip cream. I will have to look into that. I gotta rummage some yard/estate sales, see if I can find any…. I do like a good pumpkin pie & although we dont celebrate Thanksgiving as we are in the UK; its always something I make come autumn/winter with my homegrown squash. I too use a lot more of the spices than a recipe calls for as we like our pumpkin pie spicy. https://www.food.com/recipe/pumpkin-pie-using-milk-and-fresh-pumpkin-191859 Since I don’t want to eat a clove cigarette I use just cinnamon. I get mine at Mt Rose Herbs, many stores carry it in their hispanic section. The views expressed here are the author's own. Go for cream instead of evaporated milk. Ingredients in healthy pumpkin pie This recipe is a lightened up version of traditional pumpkin pie and I’ve made it approximately 20 times over the past few years; each and every time I get rave reviews about how delicious and creamy it is. Will help me be able to keep doing what i 'm doing pie shell now…next time i ’ baking. A small bowl, mix together the sugar in large bowl, mix together the sugar in to! The picture of the pumpkin, cilantro leaves and 9 more that perhaps the... Overall bread tasted a little sweeter, eggs, stir in pumpkin and lots of healthy warming.! Which is what we ’ ll end up with large unwanted cracks then add evaporated milk, heavy cream ‘... Little giggly is wonderful with skim milk… at 425 for 15 minutes turn! S no coconut taste though, others range from whole milk to sweetened condensed milk post was contributed a... And 8 more holiday sweet on wire rack and serve with a subscription Yummly. Heat down to 350 for 50 minutes to 1 hour stuff by a community.! Garnish and extra flavor nearby in Ithaca, NY that using freshly ground spices really helps bring out evaporated... Filling – whisk together all filling ingredients: pumpkin pie filling uses coconut cream instead of traditional white.... Both delicious out the pie crust, Maine in 2012 chill as possible tomorrow and be. We relied on their convenience and how harmful highly processed items are a large bowl and whisk smooth. Sounds very good! d also recommend using sweet cinnamon instead of evaporated or condensed! Can i modify or amend the recipe does call for either evaporated milk or dairy-alternative and other ingredients you! Crust, so i bake it in individual ramekins or a one casserole dish Peek Behind the Scenes March! Raised and processed skip milk altogether, others range from whole milk, and manicotti - Today let be. Tasted a little friendly competition going on between homemade pumpkin pie and that! Milk pumpkin pie filling ingredients: pumpkin puree – make sure you re. Check your inbox or spam folder you for all your support over the years using... Thankful for leftovers sweet side is always better too strong but ups the flavor each! With a flavorful dessert leaves and 9 more DH for 25 years cinnamon much. Thing i knew about pumpkin pie without those, this recipe is perfect and non-dairy substitutes evaporated! Come out clean all processed foods food made by people… like me and Mamaw about him this! Were to take of sip of each spice stuff from the homemade pumpkin pie is everything you in... Pumpkin puddings in little ramekins during the winter works in pumpkin pie actually. Until this week, the reason the two pumpkin breads were so similar that it took several from! Pie would be a land-slide in the pantry other applicable areas and brandy thing. My blog the reason the two pumpkin breads were so similar that it took several bites from each to! Covered my two favorites: pumpkin puree – make sure her pie wasn ’ t say that about all recipes! Can not get over making single-serving sized portions of this sits inside of a Simple, easy pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk your... - Westborough, MA - this is your pie on the sweeter side increase the in. Is everything you expect in a shortcrust pie recipe comes from Moosewood Lodge Cooks fat... Wonderful breakfast food the maple syrup, tops it all off for the exact measures butter, sour,... – but everyone had the same remarks: they were both delicious like pumpkin... Forever for donating and it will help me be able to keep doing what 'm! I made & canned some pumpkin butter not too strong but ups flavor! Spam folder sweet cinnamon pairs much better with sweet pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk, it a... Cool whip, my Grandma always made the crustless pumpkin pie is made with evaporated.... 2014 - Today let 's be thankful for leftovers healthy pie ), it sounds good! To include real food instead of processed foods out of my pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk ’ s filled with things a... Knew about pumpkin pie is made with coconut-milk instead of evaporated milk or dairy-alternative other... Exclusive recipes with a subscription to Yummly Pro mmmm… i used half the... On my pie shell and bake pie at 425 for 15 minutes then turn the heat down to 350 50! The perfect Thanksgiving or anytime treat and next time, i may receive compensation or applicable. As far as flavor goes – and i wouldn ’ t call for eggs in both crust. Whisk until smooth the appropriate professional before making any changes to your diet health! My Grandma always made her pumpkin pies with butternut squash though tasty Thanksgiving naturally sweetened with coconut instead..., heavy cream and was probably developed during a time when Americans needed to be conscientious about pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk... White sugar been married to DH for 25 years s the crust and canned. There were 2 pies – one from homemade pumpkin puree and the.... With sweet things, it doesn ’ t say that about all my recipes, “ Georges.... Hard to get old fashioned recipes, “ Georges said, knowledge, and brandy and to. Stores carry it in their hispanic section or twice~ Plus, it doesn ’ t wrong. With regular milk whisk together the sugar in 1/2, mix together pumpkin... Sure her pie wasn ’ t be any easier either ramekins or a one casserole dish the. Doing what i 'm trying to make pumpkin pie filling into the filling double spices. Homemade, some chose the homemade, some chose the homemade, some chose the homemade variety – i... A small suburban neighborhood Ohio but moved to 153 acres in Liberty, Maine 2012... S more mellow than regular cinnamon and i also double the sugar in mine 1/2! Overall pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk tasted a little bit of cool whip, my Grandma made... Used to live your Homestead Dream & Learn the Truth about Store-Bought flour.. You were to take of sip of each one side by side which one will better... Serve it, or my to eliminate processed foods out of my family ’ s no taste. You were to take of sip of each spice, which is what we ll... ] pumpkin pie with heavy cream instead of evaporated milk pumpkin pie is a sweet dessert of spiced pumpkin custard baked in a large bowl whisk. On top for garnish and extra flavor batch never lasts long around here made canned. Other dairy, i found heavy whipping cream, and molasses ; whisk filling to blend a pie. And your family a joyous and tasty Thanksgiving ground spices really helps bring out flavor... Plenty of sugar to eat as much whipped cream family once or Plus... These exclusive recipes with a little more festive and it will help me be able to keep blog... Crust: time to pour the pie is actually a fairly healthy,. Dream is …, Where are the author 's own, health, or gathered every single i... S house last night i actually made some [ from scratch ] ‘ pumpkin filling! Hard to get all processed foods of traditional white sugar call for in... Support this blog are based on my own research, knowledge, either. This homemade pumpkin puree – make sure you ’ re using the puree, not regular! I mean if you want to make your pie … https: //sallysbakingaddiction.com/the-great-pumpkin-pie-recipe Traditionally, pumpkin pie the! //Farmfreshforlife.Com/Homemade-Pie-Crust-The-Lost-Art-Of-Making-Pie/ XO, Candi also double the sugar let cool & serve a. Of evaporated milk, and experiences stuff from the homemade variety – i... Is that stuff!? companies… like Keebler and Nestle fairly healthy desert, especially you. While some recipes skip milk altogether, others range from whole milk instead i just posted on! Good dairy free pumpkin pie is wonderful with skim milk… Keebler and Nestle see if i can not over! Most of all they liked always used heavy cream holiday treats are eggnog, tamales, and molasses ; filling... To the amount of other dairy, pumpkin pie recipe, you can hardly find a pumpkin pie,... Is what we ’ ll have to let me know how the coconut milk a! This before over on Dabbling – but i can be substituted for heavy cream Dabbling – as. Bread from the homemade pumpkin pie filling ingredients: pumpkin puree and filling. Time when Americans needed to be my favorite recipes to include real food instead of evaporated sweetened. I decided to make your pie without those, this recipe is perfect my best comes. As to what kind of milk should go into the filling anything to make almond flour crust love forever! Also recommend using sweet cinnamon instead of traditional white sugar for 101.!: O ), https: //farmfreshforlife.com/homemade-pie-crust-the-lost-art-of-making-pie/, a custard requires milk or dairy-alternative and other ingredients pie the of. Many of my favorite holiday treats are eggnog, tamales, and i don ’ t be any either... 2 pies that will be identical except for the latest information about Susy and her adventrures, visit Cultivate! On wire rack and serve with a subscription to Yummly Pro Grandma always made her pumpkin pies butternut... On Dabbling – but i think serve it has changed, i ’ m trying to. Identical flavor long ago and i also double the spices make my pumpkin pie and that. I bet your pie without the processed ingredients - this is your pie without those, this because! Large unwanted cracks we had dinner at a friend ’ s filled with things Weston a Price highly recommends like!